So this is dedicated to the 4% of "Never Sellers" who sell without a plan.

I manage my real estate practice like an investment portfolio. Currently this portfolio has 3047 homeowners with over $2.6 Billion in home equity. The average home owner has owned their home for 14 years, many over 30 years. The number one thing they tell me is they want to live in place and leave their home to their kids. But according to their behavior in this database, 4% of them list their homes every month without a thoughtful plan and leave a considerable amount of money on the table.

Why? Because they don't have a plan.

Let's back up a little.

So they purchased their homes in the 1970s, 80s, or 90s. They raised families here, watched the neighborhood change, and in many cases have no intention of leaving.

Their homes are now worth several times what they paid. Their property taxes are often a fraction of what a new buyer would pay for the same house.

On paper, they're in a great position.

But there's a question that eventually comes up, sometimes in a conversation about retirement, sometimes after the kids have moved away, and sometimes when taking care of the house starts to feel like more work than it used to.

What do we do with the house?

It's not an easy question. The house is probably their largest financial asset, but it's also where they've spent a significant part of their lives.

I've found that many people put off the conversation because they aren't ready to make a decision. That's understandable. The problem is when something happens that takes the decision out of their hands. A fall, an illness, or the death of a spouse can suddenly force a family to figure out property taxes, capital gains, and estate planning when they have plenty of other things to deal with.

There are five options I think every longtime homeowner should understand. None is necessarily better than another. A lot depends on the homeowner's finances, family, and what they want the next ten or twenty years to look like.

1. Stay right where you are

For many people, this is the best option.

They like their neighbors, know their community, and have spent years making the house their own. Moving simply isn't something they want to do.

And financially, staying can make a lot of sense, particularly when the property tax assessment is based on a purchase made decades ago.

The consideration is whether the house will continue to work for them as they get older.

A two-story home that was perfect for raising three children may not be so convenient at 80. Maintenance, bathrooms, stairs, and even getting in and out of the house become more important.

Some fairly straightforward improvements can make a meaningful difference. Better lighting, grab bars, a walk-in shower, or converting a downstairs room into a bedroom might allow someone to stay comfortably for years.

We also have some good local resources. The Huntington Beach Senior Center in Central Park provides programs, care management, and referrals that many residents may not know are available.

Staying doesn't mean doing nothing. Sometimes it means making a plan to keep living where you want to live.

More about staying in your home

2. Sell and buy something smaller

This comes up frequently in conversations with homeowners who no longer need four bedrooms, a big yard, or a second story.

They aren't necessarily interested in leaving Huntington Beach. They might just want a single-level home with less maintenance, perhaps closer to their children or grandchildren.

One of the first concerns I hear is property taxes.

Someone paying $3,000 a year on a house they've owned for 35 years doesn't want to sell it and find themselves paying $12,000 or $15,000 annually on the next one.

That's where Proposition 19 becomes important.

California homeowners who are 55 or older may qualify to transfer their existing property tax base to a replacement primary residence anywhere in the state. The benefit can be used up to three times, provided the eligibility requirements are met.

The replacement home generally must be purchased or newly constructed within two years of the sale. Depending on the purchase price and timing, some adjustment to the transferred tax base may be required.

For someone who has owned a Huntington Beach home for decades, the difference can be substantial.

I've found that understanding the property tax consequences can completely change how someone views the possibility of moving.

How Proposition 19 works when downsizing

3. Sell the house and rent for a while

This isn't always the first option people think about, but for some homeowners it deserves consideration.

Maybe they want to spend more time near grandchildren in another state. Maybe they want to travel. Or maybe they're simply tired of being responsible for a house and don't want to immediately buy another one.

Selling provides access to the equity they've accumulated and removes many of the responsibilities of ownership.

The tradeoffs are worth understanding before making that choice.

First, there's capital gains tax.

Under current federal rules, qualifying homeowners can exclude up to $250,000 in gain from the sale of a primary residence. For eligible married couples filing jointly, that exclusion increases to $500,000.

That sounds generous until you consider someone who purchased a house in Huntington Beach for $150,000 and sells it for $1.5 million.

Even after the available exclusion, there could be a significant taxable gain.

This is also why I encourage longtime owners to locate records of major improvements they've made over the years. A room addition, qualifying remodel, or other capital improvement can increase the property's tax basis and potentially reduce the gain.

The second consideration is Proposition 19.

If a homeowner sells and decides to rent for several years, they may miss the two-year window to transfer their existing property tax base to another home.

That doesn't mean renting is a bad decision. It means the timing and financial consequences should be part of the conversation.

More about selling and renting

4. Keep the home and leave it to the children

This may be the most complicated of the five options.

Parents often assume their children will inherit the same financial advantages they've enjoyed. Unfortunately, that's not necessarily how California's property tax rules work anymore.

There are really three different issues to understand.

The first is capital gains.

Under current federal tax law, inherited property generally receives what's called a step-up in basis. In simple terms, the property's tax basis is typically adjusted to its fair market value when the owner dies.

That can eliminate a significant amount of the capital gain that accumulated during the parent's ownership.

The second issue is property taxes.

Proposition 19 changed the rules for transferring a parent's low property tax assessment to children.

To qualify for the parent-to-child principal residence exclusion, the property generally must have been the parent's principal residence and must become the child's principal residence. There are also value limits, filing deadlines, and other requirements.

If the property doesn't qualify, it can be reassessed based on current market value.

Consider a house with annual property taxes of $2,900. After reassessment, the bill could be $16,000 or more, depending on its value and applicable taxes.

That's a meaningful expense for a family that may have been hoping to keep the home.

The third issue is how the property is titled.

A properly funded living trust can allow a home to pass to heirs without going through probate.

Without the right planning, probate may be necessary, although California also has procedures that allow certain properties and estates to transfer without full probate.

The costs can surprise people.

Under California's statutory fee schedule, an estate valued at $1 million could generate approximately $23,000 in ordinary attorney fees and another $23,000 in personal representative compensation, if both receive the full statutory amounts. Court costs and other expenses can add to that.

I've come to believe that one of the most useful questions parents can ask their children is whether they actually want the house.

There's a difference between wanting to preserve the family home and wanting to preserve the financial value of the family home.

It's worth finding out which matters most before making an estate plan.

More about inherited homes and estate planning

5. Stay in the home and use some of the equity

Some homeowners have plenty of equity but would appreciate additional monthly cash flow.

They may have a relatively modest retirement income while sitting on a property worth well over a million dollars.

Selling isn't necessarily what they want to do.

For homeowners age 62 and older, one option to investigate is a Home Equity Conversion Mortgage, commonly known as a HECM reverse mortgage.

This federally insured program allows qualifying homeowners to access a portion of their home equity without making required monthly principal and interest payments while they meet the loan conditions.

The loan balance grows as interest and fees accumulate, and homeowners remain responsible for property taxes, insurance, maintenance, and other requirements.

There are protections for borrowers and eligible heirs, and HUD-approved counseling is required.

Reverse mortgages have costs and limitations. They're not a solution for everyone, and I would encourage anyone considering one to review it carefully with a qualified professional and their family.

But I also wouldn't dismiss the option without understanding how it works.

Understanding reverse mortgages

Before making a decision

One thing I've learned is that these decisions get easier when families have the information in front of them.

I generally suggest starting with three things.

Find the most recent property tax bill. Locate the original purchase documents and whatever records are available for major improvements. And pull out the estate planning documents, including any trust, will, and the deed to the property.

Even if those documents haven't been reviewed in twenty years, they're a starting point.

From there, a CPA can help evaluate the tax consequences. An estate planning attorney can review how the property will transfer. A knowledgeable local Realtor can help establish what the home is worth, what a sale might cost, and what replacement housing options actually exist.

You don't have to be ready to sell to benefit from that information.

In fact, I think it's better to have these conversations when nobody is under pressure to make a decision.

I've put together a free guide for longtime Huntington Beach homeowners and their families that goes into these five options in more detail.

You can read it here, without registering or providing any personal information:

https://youroptions.homes/?c=linkedin

And if you're an adult son or daughter trying to help your parents figure out what comes next, I hope you'll share it with them.

The same goes for CPAs, estate planning attorneys, and financial advisors who work with families facing these decisions.

I

've spent a good deal of time thinking about how to help homeowners make these decisions without turning every conversation into a discussion about selling their house.

Sometimes selling makes sense. Sometimes it doesn't.

What matters is that people understand their options while they still have the freedom to choose.

Marc Samulewicz, REALTOR®, SRES®

Real Estate Advisor | Seven Gables Real Estate

Founder, hb.homes

CA DRE #02336405

(714) 887-7266

https://hb.homes

This article is for general educational purposes and is not tax, legal, mortgage, or financial advice. Individual circumstances vary. Consult the appropriate professionals before making decisions.